Determining Fault in a New York Personal Injury Case

In personal injury cases, establishing fault is a critical step that significantly influences whether an injured party can recover compensation and how much they might receive. New York’s laws around personal injury and negligence play a vital role in determining who is legally responsible for injuries sustained in car accidents, slips and falls, workplace accidents, and other incidents. Below, we explore the key factors and legal standards that guide fault determination in New York personal injury cases. For personalized assistance related to an accident or injury in Ulster County or New York’s Hudson Valley, contact Rusk, Wadlin, Heppner & Martuscello, LLP to speak with an experienced and dedicated Kingston personal injury lawyer.

The Basics of Fault in Personal Injury Cases

Fault in a personal injury case often comes down to determining who acted negligently or recklessly. New York law mandates that people and entities exercise reasonable care to avoid causing harm to others. When someone breaches this duty, and their actions (or inactions) result in injury, they may be held liable for damages.

Fault, however, isn’t always straightforward. In many cases, multiple parties may share responsibility, or liability may be disputed. New York follows a “pure comparative negligence” rule, meaning that each party involved in an accident can bear a percentage of fault based on their contribution to the incident. This rule impacts the compensation that the injured party can receive, making it essential to clearly establish and quantify fault.

Understanding Negligence in New York

In personal injury cases, fault is most often linked to the concept of negligence. To prove that another party was negligent, the injured person (plaintiff) typically must show four elements:

1. Duty of Care: The defendant owed a legal duty of care to the plaintiff.

2. Breach of Duty: The defendant breached that duty by failing to act as a reasonably prudent person would.

3. Causation: The defendant’s breach of duty directly caused the plaintiff’s injuries.

4. Damages: The plaintiff suffered actual damages, such as medical bills, lost wages, or pain and suffering, due to the injuries.

In New York, the burden of proving each of these elements falls on the plaintiff. The court or jury will weigh the evidence to determine if the defendant’s actions, or lack thereof, were the cause of the injuries.

New York’s Comparative Negligence Rule

New York adheres to a pure comparative negligence standard, which plays a unique role in determining fault. Under this rule, even if an injured person shares some degree of responsibility for the accident, they can still recover compensation. However, the amount of compensation will be reduced according to the percentage of their fault.

For example, if a pedestrian is found to be 20% responsible for a car accident because they crossed outside the crosswalk where they didn’t have the right of way, their total award will be reduced by 20%. So, if they were awarded $100,000, they would only receive $80,000 after the reduction. This approach underscores the importance of accurately assessing each party’s role in an accident to ensure a fair distribution of fault.

Key Factors in Determining Fault

Fault determination in a personal injury case often hinges on multiple factors, including the type of accident, the circumstances leading to it, and the evidence available. Some key pieces of evidence in an injury claim might include, for example:

1. Police Reports: In cases involving car accidents or violent incidents, police reports can be valuable evidence. The report may include details about the scene, eyewitness accounts, and any citations issued, helping to establish who may be at fault.

2. Eyewitness Testimony: Statements from people who witnessed the accident can provide an unbiased perspective on what happened. Eyewitnesses may shed light on the actions of each party, which can influence the court’s determination of fault.

3. Video Footage: Surveillance cameras, dash cams, and other recording devices can offer a clear view of the events leading to the accident. Video evidence can serve as a crucial tool in assessing fault, as it provides an objective account of the incident.

4. Expert Witnesses: In cases involving complex situations—like multi-car accidents, unsafe premises or industrial injuries—expert witnesses can offer their professional insights. Accident reconstruction experts, for example, can analyze the scene, the vehicles involved, and other details to help determine how the incident occurred.

5. Medical Records: In cases where the extent of injuries plays a role in fault determination, medical records can establish the connection between the accident and the injury. They can also indicate whether the injuries are consistent with the type of accident reported.

Determining Fault in Different Types of Accidents

Fault determination can vary depending on the type of personal injury case. Here’s how fault is typically assessed in some of the most common cases:

• Car Accidents: In car accident cases, determining fault may involve examining driving behaviors, such as speeding, distracted driving, or failure to obey traffic signals. New York’s “no-fault” insurance system provides that each driver’s insurance covers their own injuries, regardless of fault, but serious injuries can lead to a personal injury lawsuit where fault must be established.

• Slip and Fall Accidents: For premises liability cases, like slip and falls, property owners are generally responsible for keeping their premises safe. Determining fault often focuses on whether the property owner created the dangerous condition or if they knew or should have known about a hazard, and if they took reasonable steps to address it.

• Workplace Injuries: In New York, most workplace injuries are covered by workers’ compensation, which doesn’t require proof of fault. However, if a third party (such as a subcontractor or equipment manufacturer) contributed to the injury, a personal injury claim may arise, necessitating a fault assessment.

The Role of Insurance Companies in Fault Determination

Insurance companies play a significant role in fault determination for personal injury cases, especially in car accidents. Adjusters investigate claims, review evidence, and decide on fault percentages. However, insurers’ conclusions may not always be in the best interest of the injured party. They often aim to minimize payouts, which can result in lower fault percentages for their insureds.

Because insurance companies have a vested interest, it’s important to consult with a personal injury attorney who can advocate for a fair and accurate fault determination. An attorney can gather evidence, work with experts, and negotiate effectively with insurers, helping to prevent unjust reductions in compensation.

How a Personal Injury Lawyer Can Help

Determining fault in a personal injury case can be a complex and time-sensitive process. At Rusk, Wadlin, Heppner & Martuscello, LLP, our experienced personal injury attorneys work diligently to gather the necessary evidence, consult with experts, and build strong cases on behalf of our clients. We understand New York’s comparative negligence laws and are committed to maximizing compensation for injured clients, even in cases where fault is shared.

If you or a loved one has been injured in the Hudson Valley, reach out to our personal injury law firm for a free consultation. Contact us at our offices in Kingston at 845-331-4100 or Marlboro at 845-236-4411, or call 800-566-4101 throughout the Hudson Valley. We’ll help you navigate the complexities of your case, determine fault, and pursue the compensation you deserve.

Share This Page: